3 November 2026
Baby Pool Rules: Scoring, Ties and Prizes
Baby pool rules that keep things fair: what to guess, when to close entries, how scoring works, how to settle ties and what to give the winner.

A fair baby pool comes down to five rules, agreed before anyone makes a guess: what people are guessing, when guesses close, how points work, how ties are settled, and what the winner gets. Write them down in one place, share them with the invite, and the pool runs itself.
If you host the pool on GuessOurBaby, guests need no app or account, the host pays a one-off $19 fee (£14.99 in the UK, €17.99 in the EU). Launch code LAUNCH70 is 70% off ($5.70 / £4.50 / €5.40) while available. There is no subscription.
Most baby pool arguments start after the birth: two people tie, or an aunt guessed after the baby arrived. This guide gives you simple rules for each moment, plus a version to copy and paste.
New to this? Read what is a baby pool or our baby pool game guide first, or see how to create a baby pool online for the setup steps.
The five baby pool rules at a glance
- Rule 1, questions: decide what people can guess. A sensible default is date, gender, weight and one fun extra.
- Rule 2, deadline: decide when guesses close. A sensible default is before the baby could arrive.
- Rule 3, scoring: decide how points are awarded. A sensible default is that the closest guess scores most.
- Rule 4, tiebreaker: decide who wins if scores match. A sensible default is closest to the birth, then earliest entry.
- Rule 5, prize: decide what the winner gets. A sensible default is something small and non-cash.
Rule 1: Decide what everyone is guessing
Keep the list short. Three to five questions is plenty, because every extra question is one more thing for guests to skip and one more thing for you to score.
The classics work for a reason:
- Birth date, the one everybody expects
- Time of birth
- Gender, if the parents are finding out beforehand or at birth
- Birth weight
- Baby's name
Add one playful extra if you like, such as hair color or a message for the baby. If you need ideas, our list of baby prediction game ideas has plenty. For weight, state whether guesses are in pounds and ounces (lb and oz) or kilograms, so nobody argues about units later. If most of your guests are in the US, lb and oz will feel the most natural.
Rule 2: Set a deadline for guesses
Decide when entries close and say so in the invite. The usual choices are the date of the baby shower, a set number of weeks before the due date, or simply "before the baby arrives".
A due date is an estimate. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) puts the average length of pregnancy at 40 weeks, or 280 days, counted from the first day of the last period, and the NHS says pregnancy normally lasts from 37 to 42 weeks. Closing guesses before 37 weeks means nobody can guess after the baby could realistically be on the way. That cut-off is our suggestion rather than an official rule, but it keeps things honest.
Rule 3: Choose how points work
The obvious method, "closest to the due date wins", sounds simple, but real births rarely land on the day.
According to UK data from the Perinatal Institute, reported by the BBC, only about 4% of babies are born on their predicted due date (4.4% if premature births and pregnancies with complications are left out). For straightforward, low-risk pregnancies, around 60% arrive within a week either side of the date, and more than 90% within two weeks. In other words, scoring only for an exact date match would leave most pools without a single exact winner.
There are three common ways to score a baby pool.
Closest wins, category by category. Each question has its own winner. It is easy to explain, but it crowns several people and no overall winner.
Fixed points for exact answers. Give 10 points for the right gender, 10 for the right name and so on. It works well for questions with a yes-or-no answer, but it is harsh on dates and weights, where a near miss deserves some credit.
Points scaled by how close you got. A guess that is one day out scores almost full marks, and the score fades the further away it gets. This is the fairest method for dates, times and weights, and it is the hardest to do by hand.
How GuessOurBaby scores a pool
We use the third approach, with each question worth a different number of points depending on how hard it is to guess:
- Birth date, up to 40 points: scaled by distance, falling to zero at 21 days out.
- Birth time, up to 15 points: scaled by distance, falling to zero at 12 hours out.
- Birth weight, up to 14 points: scaled by distance, falling to zero at about 3 lb (1.36 kg) out.
- Baby's name, up to 12 points: exact match, ignoring capitals and punctuation.
- Gender, up to 10 points: exact match.
- Length, up to 8 points: scaled by distance, falling to zero at 12 cm (about 4.7 inches) out.
- Eye color, hair color, 6 points each: exact match.
- Number of babies, up to 5 points: exact match.
- First letter of the name, birth month, multiple-choice custom questions, 4 points each: exact match.
Only the questions you switch on count toward the total, and free-text questions such as a message for the baby are not scored. Using this scale, a date guess one day out scores 38 of 40 points and a guess a week out scores 27. A weight guess 8 oz off scores 12 of 14, and one 1 lb off scores 9. Gender is worth fewer points than the date because it is far easier to get right by chance.
Rule 4: Agree a tiebreaker before you need one
Ties are rare when scoring is scaled by closeness, but they still happen, and they are the moment people care most. Decide the order in advance:
- First: the guess closest to the actual date and time of birth wins.
- Second: if still level, the person with more exact answers wins.
- Third: if still level, the earliest entry wins, because they committed first.
GuessOurBaby applies exactly this order on the leaderboard, and only declares a shared win if every one of those checks is level. If you run the pool on paper, write the order at the top of the sheet.
Rule 5: Pick a prize, and think before you charge an entry fee
The best prizes are small and a bit silly: a homemade trophy, bragging rights or a coffee gift card. A prize worth a few dollars keeps the focus on the fun.
Be more careful with money. In the US, a lottery is generally defined by three things: a prize, chance, and payment to enter. A California Attorney General opinion, for example, describes those three elements, and an entry fee can count as the payment. Gambling rules differ by state, and Canada and other countries have their own, so a cash pool can be fine in one place and not in another.
Most families sidestep all of this by playing for free, or by agreeing a non-cash prize. If you do plan to collect money, check your state or provincial rules first. This is general information, not legal advice.
Edge cases to settle up front
A few situations catch hosts out, so mention them in your rules:
- Planned C-sections and inductions. The date is chosen in advance, so say whether a scheduled birth counts. Most pools simply use the actual date and time of birth.
- Twins or more. Decide which birth time counts, usually the first baby's.
- Late entries. If someone guesses after the baby is born, their guess does not count. The deadline in rule 2 should be firm.
Baby pool rules you can copy and paste
Drop this straight into your invite or group chat and edit as you like:
Baby pool rules
- Guesses: everyone gets one guess each: date, time, gender, weight and name.
- Deadline: guesses close on [date]. Late guesses do not count.
- Scoring: points are given for how close you are. The closest guess scores most.
- Ties: if scores tie, the winner is whoever was closest to the actual birth, then whoever had more exact answers, then whoever entered first.
- Final say: the parents confirm the final details and their decision is final.
- Prize: the winner gets [prize]. No money changes hands.
Let the leaderboard do the counting
With GuessOurBaby you choose the questions, share one link, and the leaderboard works out the points and the winner when you add the real birth details. Guests need no app or account, and the guesses stay saved as a keepsake page. It is a one-off payment with no subscription.
Frequently asked questions
What are the rules of a baby pool?
A baby pool needs five rules: what people can guess, a deadline for guesses, how points are scored, how ties are settled, and what the prize is. Agree them before the first guess comes in and share them with the invite.
How do you score a baby pool?
The fairest way is to give points for how close a guess is, rather than only for an exact match. A date guess one day out should score almost as much as an exact one. Exact-match scoring suits yes-or-no questions such as gender.
What happens if two people tie in a baby pool?
Use a tiebreaker you agreed in advance. A common order is closest to the actual birth date and time, then the most exact answers, then whoever entered first.
When should guesses close in a baby pool?
Close guesses before the baby could arrive. The NHS says pregnancy normally lasts from 37 to 42 weeks, and ACOG counts 37 weeks as the start of term, so closing before 37 weeks is a safe suggestion. Many hosts simply use the baby shower date.
Do you have to bet money in a baby pool?
No. Many baby pools are free and play for bragging rights or a small non-cash prize. If you collect money, check your state or provincial rules first, because an entry fee plus a prize can fall under gambling or lottery laws.
How many babies are born on their due date?
Only a small number. UK data from the Perinatal Institute, reported by the BBC, puts it at about 4% of births, which is why scoring should reward near misses.
Final Answer
To run a fair baby pool, agree five things up front: the questions, the deadline, the scoring, the tiebreaker and the prize. Score by closeness, because very few babies arrive on the due date, and keep the prize light. When you would rather not do the math, let an online leaderboard handle it.
Create your own baby pool when you're ready
Use these ideas as your starting point, then build a baby prediction game your friends and family can join in seconds.
Keep reading
13 November 2026
Baby Pool Etiquette: What Guests Should Know
Baby pool etiquette for guests, from when to submit predictions to what makes a thoughtful guess, plus tips on messages and gracious losing.
13 November 2026
How to Host a Virtual Baby Pool for Remote Family
A step-by-step guide to hosting a virtual baby pool for long-distance family and friends, from sharing the link to revealing the winner online.
11 November 2026
Best Baby Pool Sites 2026: Free & Paid Options Compared
Fair comparison of the best baby pool websites for 2026, including GuessOurBaby and free alternatives. What each is good for, pricing, and how to choose.