6 November 2026
Baby Pool Prizes: Ideas and How to Choose
Baby pool prize ideas that feel thoughtful without breaking the bank, from coffee gift cards to spa treats, plus tips on choosing the right prize.

When you are running a baby pool, the question of prizes comes up fairly quickly.
Do you need one? What kind? How much should it cost? And does it need to be baby-related, or is that actually a bit weird?
The short answer is that a prize makes the game feel more official, but it does not need to be expensive or elaborate. Most people pick something small, useful, and genuinely pleasant to receive.
This guide covers what works, what does not, and how to choose a baby pool prize that feels right for your group.
Do You Actually Need a Prize?
Not always, but it helps.
A baby pool prize gives people a reason to take their guesses seriously. It also makes the winner reveal feel more like an event, rather than just a leaderboard update.
That said, plenty of families skip the prize entirely. If your baby pool is mostly close family, or if everyone is just there for the fun of guessing, you do not need to force it.
But if you are inviting work colleagues, extended family, or a larger group of friends, a prize makes the whole thing feel more complete. It signals that someone wins, and that winning matters at least a little bit.
What Makes a Good Baby Pool Prize
The best baby pool prizes share a few qualities:
- small enough to feel reasonable
- nice enough to actually want
- easy to deliver or hand over
- not awkward to receive
In other words, aim for something that sits comfortably between "thoughtful gesture" and "actual reward."
Avoid anything too personal, too niche, or too obviously re-gifted. And unless you know the winner really well, steer clear of anything related to babies. The prize is for the person who guessed correctly, not for the baby.
Baby Pool Prize Ideas That Actually Work
Here are some options that have worked well for other hosts.
Coffee or Tea Gift Cards
A £10 or £15 coffee shop gift card is one of the most reliable baby pool prizes you can choose.
Everyone likes coffee. Even people who do not drink coffee usually drink tea or hot chocolate. And gift cards are easy to send by email if the winner is not local.
This works especially well for:
- work baby pools
- larger family groups
- pools with long-distance participants
Candles or Home Fragrance
A nice candle feels like a treat without being too specific.
Go for something neutral and widely liked, like vanilla, citrus, or lavender. Avoid anything too strong or divisive.
This is a good option if you want something physical to hand over at a baby shower, and it photographs well if you plan to share the winner announcement online.
Spa or Self-Care Treats
Small self-care items work nicely as baby pool prizes because they feel indulgent without costing too much.
Think:
- bath salts or bath oil
- hand cream sets
- face masks
- small skincare gift sets
These are widely appreciated, easy to wrap, and fit well into the "treat yourself" category.
Wine, Beer, or Spirits
If your group drinks alcohol, a decent bottle of wine or a craft beer selection makes a solid baby pool prize.
This works especially well for:
- adult-only baby pools
- colleague or friend groups
- casual pools where everyone knows each other
Just make sure the winner is someone who drinks. If you are not certain, go with something else.
Chocolate or Sweet Treats
A box of nice chocolates is simple, universally liked, and always feels like a win.
Go for something a bit fancier than supermarket chocolate, but nothing too obscure. The goal is "this is lovely" rather than "I have no idea what this is."
This is one of the easiest baby pool prizes to deliver in person, and it works for almost any group.
Small Plant or Succulent
A small potted plant feels thoughtful and lasts longer than chocolate or candles.
Succulents are particularly good because they are low-maintenance and hard to kill. Avoid anything that needs a lot of care or specific conditions.
This works best if you are handing over the prize in person. Posting a plant is messy and usually not worth the effort.
Books or Stationery
If your group is on the bookish side, a paperback or a nice notebook makes a lovely baby pool prize.
Go for something fairly general, like a bestselling novel or a beautiful blank journal. Avoid anything too specific unless you know the winner well.
This is a good middle-ground option if you want something with a bit more thought behind it, but still practical.
Experience Vouchers
For a slightly larger budget, consider a small experience voucher:
- cinema tickets
- afternoon tea
- mini spa treatment
- restaurant voucher
These feel more generous without necessarily costing much more, and they give the winner something to look forward to.
This works well if you know the winner is local and likely to use it.
How Much Should You Spend on a Baby Pool Prize?
Most baby pool prizes sit somewhere between £10 and £25.
That is enough to feel generous without making anyone uncomfortable. If you go much higher, it starts to feel less like a game and more like a sweepstake, which changes the tone.
If your baby pool is small and informal, £10 is perfectly fine. If it is larger or more structured, £20 to £25 feels about right.
Remember that the prize is a gesture, not a jackpot. The real reward is being right, and having bragging rights for the next year.
Should You Announce the Prize in Advance?
Yes, usually.
Announcing the prize early makes the game feel more official and gives people an extra reason to join in. It also sets expectations, so nobody is surprised when the winner is announced.
You can mention the prize when you share the baby pool link:
- "Winner gets a £15 coffee gift card"
- "Best guess wins a bottle of wine"
- "Closest prediction gets a spa gift set"
Keep it simple and clear. You do not need to oversell it.
If you have not decided on a prize yet, that is fine too. Just add it to the baby pool description once you know.
What If Multiple People Tie?
Ties are rare in baby pools, but they can happen.
Most baby pool platforms have a built-in tiebreaker, usually based on:
- who submitted their guess earliest
- who got more exact matches
If your platform does not handle this automatically, you can:
- split the prize between tied winners
- pick one winner at random
- give both winners a smaller version of the prize
The fairest approach is usually to split it, especially if the prize is a gift card or something easily divisible.
If you are giving a physical item like a candle or a plant, you might need to pick one winner. Just be clear about how the tiebreaker works before the pool goes live.
Should the Prize Be Baby-Themed?
Not usually.
The prize is for the person who guessed correctly, not for the baby. Unless the winner specifically asked for baby-related items, it is safer to choose something they can enjoy themselves.
There are a few exceptions:
- if the winner is also expecting a baby
- if you know they are actively looking for baby items
- if the prize is something neutral like a gift card they could use on anything
In general, though, a non-baby prize is the safer choice.
Do You Need a Prize for a Family Baby Pool?
Not always.
If your baby pool is mostly immediate family, a prize might feel unnecessary. The fun of guessing and the bragging rights might be enough.
That said, even in family baby pools, a small prize can make the reveal feel more fun. It does not need to be anything big. A box of chocolates or a bottle of wine is often enough to make it feel like an event.
If you are not sure, you can always ask the family group what they think. Some families love prizes. Others genuinely do not care.
How to Present the Baby Pool Prize
If you are handing over the prize in person, make it part of the winner reveal moment.
You could:
- announce the winner at a gathering and hand over the prize there
- post the prize with a handwritten note
- drop it off in person if the winner is local
If the winner is not nearby, a digital gift card is the easiest option. Send it by email along with a message congratulating them on their excellent guessing skills.
You can also share a photo of the winner with their prize on social media or in your family group chat, especially if other people were part of the baby pool. It makes the win feel more official.
What If You Forget to Choose a Prize?
It happens.
If you launch the baby pool without deciding on a prize, you can always add one later. Just update the baby pool description and let people know.
Most guests will not mind. The main thing is that the game feels fair and the winner gets some kind of acknowledgment.
If you completely forget and the baby has already arrived, you can still award a prize retroactively. Just reach out to the winner, apologize for the delay, and send them something nice. Nobody will hold it against you.
Final Answer
A baby pool prize does not need to be expensive or elaborate. The best prizes are small, thoughtful, and easy to deliver.
Coffee gift cards, candles, chocolates, and self-care treats all work well. Aim for something in the £10 to £25 range, announce it early, and make sure it is for the winner, not the baby.
If you want to set up a baby pool with a clear prize displayed on the page, you can create one here.
Create your own baby pool when you're ready
Use these ideas as your starting point, then build a baby prediction game your friends and family can join in seconds.
Keep reading
13 November 2026
Baby Pool Etiquette: What Guests Should Know
Baby pool etiquette for guests, from when to submit predictions to what makes a thoughtful guess, plus tips on messages and gracious losing.
13 November 2026
How to Host a Virtual Baby Pool for Remote Family
A step-by-step guide to hosting a virtual baby pool for long-distance family and friends, from sharing the link to revealing the winner online.
11 November 2026
Best Baby Pool Sites 2026: Free & Paid Options Compared
Fair comparison of the best baby pool websites for 2026, including GuessOurBaby and free alternatives. What each is good for, pricing, and how to choose.